Detailed Summary
The Resignation of Pope Benedict XVI
The movie begins with Pope Benedict XVI (Anthony Hopkins) in 2012, contemplating his decision to resign from the papacy—the first to do so in nearly 600 years. Meanwhile, Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio (Jonathan Pryce), a liberal Argentine bishop, is preparing to submit his resignation as he grows frustrated with the direction of the Church.
The Meeting Between Two Opposing Ideologies
Cardinal Bergoglio travels to Rome at the request of Pope Benedict. The two men—representing contrasting views of the Catholic Church—engage in a series of candid, philosophical, and often humorous conversations. Benedict, a traditionalist, and Bergoglio, a reformer, clash over issues such as doctrine, modernity, and the Church’s handling of scandals.
Flashbacks to Bergoglio’s Past
The film frequently flashes back to pivotal moments in Bergoglio’s life, including his role during Argentina’s Dirty War. These scenes provide insight into his personal struggles with faith, his journey to the priesthood, and his grappling with the guilt of not doing enough during the dictatorship.
Pope Benedict’s Confession
In a critical moment, Pope Benedict confides in Bergoglio about his own failings, including his mishandling of the Church’s abuse scandals. This marks a turning point in their relationship as Benedict begins to see Bergoglio as his potential successor.
The Decision and The Future
Benedict shocks the world by resigning in 2013, paving the way for Bergoglio to become Pope Francis. The film ends with the two Popes watching the World Cup together, highlighting their newfound friendship and mutual respect.
Movie Ending
The film concludes with Pope Francis assuming the papacy, symbolizing a new chapter for the Catholic Church. The final scene shows the two men, now friends, enjoying a casual moment watching football together—an unexpected yet touching depiction of their shared humanity and humor.
Are There Post-Credits Scenes?
No, “The Two Popes” does not have any post-credits scenes.
Type of Movie
This film is a biographical drama with comedic elements, focusing on a dialogue-driven exploration of faith, leadership, and change within the Catholic Church.
Cast
- Anthony Hopkins as Pope Benedict XVI
- Jonathan Pryce as Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio (Pope Francis)
- Juan Minujín as young Jorge Bergoglio
- Sidney Cole as Cardinal Turkson
Film Music and Composer
The score is composed by Bryce Dessner, with a mix of classical music and contemporary songs that reflect the contrast between the two main characters. The use of tango music is a nod to Bergoglio’s Argentine heritage.
Filming Locations
- Rome, Italy: Key scenes, including the Vatican settings, were shot in Rome, although the Sistine Chapel was meticulously recreated on a set.
- Buenos Aires, Argentina: The flashback scenes showing Bergoglio’s early life and his time during the dictatorship were filmed in Argentina.
The locations play a crucial role in contrasting the grandeur of the Vatican with the more modest and urban settings of Bergoglio’s past.
Awards and Nominations
- Academy Awards: Nominated for Best Actor (Jonathan Pryce), Best Supporting Actor (Anthony Hopkins), and Best Adapted Screenplay.
- Golden Globe Awards: Nominated for Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Drama (Jonathan Pryce) and Best Supporting Actor (Anthony Hopkins).
- BAFTA Awards: Nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Actor (Jonathan Pryce).
Behind the Scenes Insights
- Jonathan Pryce’s resemblance to Pope Francis played a significant role in his casting, something even the actor himself had noticed.
- The film’s dialogue was largely inspired by the actual letters and public statements of both Popes, although the meetings depicted in the film are fictionalized.
- The Sistine Chapel set was so accurate that even experts found it hard to differentiate from the real one.
Inspirations and References
- The film is based on true events, inspired by the relationship between Pope Benedict XVI and Pope Francis.
- The screenplay is adapted from the play “The Pope” by Anthony McCarten, who also wrote the screenplay for the film.
Alternate Endings and Deleted Scenes
There are no known alternate endings or significant deleted scenes for this film, as it follows a cohesive narrative arc focused on the two central figures.
Book Adaptations and Differences
While not directly adapted from a specific book, the movie is based on Anthony McCarten’s play. The film expands on the source material by adding more flashbacks and personal moments.
Memorable Scenes and Quotes
Key Scenes
- The Confession: Pope Benedict’s emotional confession to Bergoglio about his struggles and guilt.
- The Tango Dance: A flashback scene showing Bergoglio dancing tango in his youth, representing his connection to Argentina and his love for the people.
- The World Cup Watch Party: The final scene where the two Popes bond over a football match, showing the lighter side of their relationship.
Iconic Quotes
- “Silence is not an absence; it is a presence.” – Pope Benedict XVI
- “Truth may be vital, but without love, it is unbearable.” – Pope Benedict XVI
- “Change is compromise. It is a compromise between who we were and who we are called to be.” – Cardinal Bergoglio
Easter Eggs and Hidden Details
- The scene where Bergoglio orders pizza in Rome hints at Pope Francis’s down-to-earth nature and preference for simplicity.
- In the recreated Sistine Chapel, subtle lighting changes highlight the shifts in tone during the theological discussions.
Trivia
- Both Jonathan Pryce and Anthony Hopkins were nominated for Oscars for their performances, making this one of the rare films where both leads were nominated.
- The real Pope Francis reportedly appreciated the film, particularly its human portrayal of both him and Benedict.
- The tango scenes were choreographed to authentically reflect Argentine culture.
Why Watch?
“The Two Popes” captivates viewers with its exploration of faith, tradition, and transformation. The film engages those interested in religious history or dialogue-rich dramas by showcasing how two contrasting leaders navigate their differences and ultimately discover shared understanding.
Director’s Other Movies
- City of God (2002)
- The Constant Gardener (2005)
- Blindness (2008)
- 360 (2011)
- The Great Beauty (2013) (As an inspiration)
Recommended Films for Fans
- Spotlight (2015)
- Doubt (2008)
- The Queen (2006)
- A Man for All Seasons (1966)
- Silence (2016)
