Alan J. Pakula’s Sophie’s Choice (1982) is one of the most powerful dramas ever put on screen, adapted from William Styron’s acclaimed novel. It is a film about memory, trauma, love, and the devastating cost of survival.
Detailed Summary
Arrival in Brooklyn
The story is told through the eyes of Stingo (Peter MacNicol), a young aspiring writer from the South who moves to Brooklyn in 1947. He rents a room in a pink boarding house and soon meets the eccentric, charismatic Nathan (Kevin Kline) and his Polish girlfriend Sophie (Meryl Streep).
Sophie and Nathan’s Unstable Love
Stingo is drawn into the whirlwind of Sophie and Nathan’s relationship. Nathan is brilliant, charming, and generous, but he is also deeply unstable and abusive. Sophie, elegant and vulnerable, remains devoted to him despite his destructive outbursts. Their love oscillates between tender passion and violent breakdowns, leaving Stingo both fascinated and concerned.
Sophie’s Past Revealed
As Stingo grows closer to Sophie, she gradually opens up about her past in Poland during World War II. We learn that she was the daughter of a Polish professor and that, despite not being Jewish, she was arrested and sent to Auschwitz. Her survival came at an unimaginable moral cost—something she carries like a ghost.
The Choice
The most harrowing moment of Sophie’s past is revealed in a gut-wrenching flashback: upon arriving at Auschwitz, a Nazi officer forces her to make an impossible decision—choose which of her two children will live, and which will be sent to death. When she begs to be spared from making the choice, the officer coldly tells her that if she refuses, both children will die. In a moment of unbearable torment, Sophie chooses to save her son, condemning her daughter to the gas chamber. This moment defines Sophie’s entire existence and haunts every step of her life afterward.
Movie Ending
In the final act, Stingo, increasingly disturbed by Nathan’s violent outbursts and paranoid delusions, tries to convince Sophie to leave him. He even proposes that she run away with him to the South. Sophie briefly seems willing, spending a night with Stingo in what feels like an attempt to grasp a new life.
But Sophie cannot escape her past or her bond with Nathan. The next day, Stingo discovers the tragic truth: Sophie and Nathan have committed suicide together. Their bodies are found in bed, locked in each other’s arms. Sophie, unable to live with the weight of her choice and her survivor’s guilt, has chosen death as her final release.
This devastating ending makes clear that the trauma of her past was inescapable, and the “choice” she was forced to make in Auschwitz continued to dictate her fate long after the war ended.
Are There Post-Credits Scenes?
No, Sophie’s Choice does not include any post-credits scenes. The story ends with its haunting conclusion, and the credits roll in silence, allowing the viewer to sit with the emotional weight of what they’ve just witnessed.
Type of Movie
This is a historical drama with elements of romance and psychological tragedy. It is not a Holocaust film in the traditional sense but rather a character-driven story about memory, guilt, and survival.
Cast
- Meryl Streep as Sophie Zawistowski
- Kevin Kline as Nathan Landau
- Peter MacNicol as Stingo
- Rita Karin as Yetta Zimmerman
- Greta Turken as Leslie Lapidus
Film Music and Composer
The score was composed by Marvin Hamlisch, blending classical influences with a deeply emotional undertone. The music is subtle, never overshadowing the performances but heightening the tragic weight of Sophie’s story.
⇢ KEEP UP WITH THE TREND
Filming Locations
- Brooklyn, New York: Much of the film was shot in actual Brooklyn neighborhoods, grounding the story in post-war America.
- Washington, D.C. and Virginia: Used for some of Stingo’s background scenes.
- Auschwitz flashbacks: Filmed partly in Poland to bring authenticity to Sophie’s backstory. These locations carry immense significance, lending emotional and historical gravity.
Awards and Nominations
- Academy Awards: Meryl Streep won the Oscar for Best Actress (widely regarded as one of the greatest performances in film history). The film also received nominations for Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design, Best Music, and Best Adapted Screenplay.
- Golden Globes: Streep also won Best Actress in a Drama.
- Multiple critics’ associations lauded the film for its performances and adaptation.
Behind the Scenes Insights
- Meryl Streep personally lobbied for the role of Sophie, reportedly sending Alan J. Pakula a passionate letter explaining why she had to play the character.
- Kevin Kline made his film debut as Nathan, and his intense performance was a revelation.
- Streep mastered Polish and German dialogue for authenticity, impressing both critics and native speakers.
- The Auschwitz flashback sequence was emotionally draining for the cast and crew—Streep later admitted she felt physically ill after filming Sophie’s “choice” scene.
Inspirations and References
The film is based on William Styron’s 1979 novel Sophie’s Choice, which itself was inspired by survivor accounts of the Holocaust. Styron wanted to explore the lasting psychological scars of trauma rather than depict the Holocaust directly.
Alternate Endings and Deleted Scenes
No alternate ending was filmed; Pakula stayed faithful to the novel’s tragic conclusion. Some minor scenes were trimmed for pacing, but nothing significantly changed the story’s impact.
Book Adaptations and Differences
The movie closely follows the novel but condenses Stingo’s backstory. In the book, his Southern roots and struggles as a writer are given more detail. The film places greater focus on Sophie and Nathan, streamlining Stingo into a narrative observer.
⇢ MOST SHARED RIGHT NOW
Memorable Scenes and Quotes
Key Scenes
- Sophie arriving in Auschwitz and being forced to make the choice.
- Nathan’s manic episodes of rage and then his sudden tenderness toward Sophie.
- Sophie and Stingo’s tender night together, filled with unspoken despair.
- The discovery of Sophie and Nathan’s suicide.
Iconic Quotes
- Sophie: “I have never told that to anyone in the world.”
- Nathan: “You’re mine, Sophie. Mine.”
- Stingo: “This was not judgment day – only morning. Morning: excellent and fair.”
Easter Eggs and Hidden Details
- Styron’s own Southern background is mirrored in Stingo, making him a semi-autobiographical character.
- Sophie’s costumes subtly shift throughout the film: bright and floral in moments of hope, darker and muted as her despair deepens.
- Pakula often frames Sophie through windows or behind glass, visually reinforcing her sense of entrapment.
Trivia
- Meryl Streep’s performance is considered one of the greatest in cinema history; the “choice” scene is studied in acting schools worldwide.
- Kevin Kline originally trained as an opera singer before turning to acting, which added depth to Nathan’s manic charisma.
- Peter MacNicol, who played Stingo, went on to have a long career in TV and film, though this role remains his most iconic.
Why Watch?
Because Sophie’s Choice is not just a movie—it’s an emotional experience. It features one of the greatest performances ever filmed, it tells a deeply human story about trauma and love, and it dares to explore moral dilemmas that most stories never touch. It is devastating, unforgettable, and essential cinema.
Director’s Other Movies
- All the President’s Men (1976)
- Klute (1971)
- Presumed Innocent (1990)
- The Pelican Brief (1993)
